View Single Post
  #2   Report Post  
Old August 31st 04, 03:25 AM posted to sci.environment,sci.geo.meteorology,alt.global-warming,talk.environment
Roger Coppock Roger Coppock is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by Weather-Banter: May 2005
Posts: 1,360
Default The Idsos' co2science web site has an error in the MSU data calculation page

Eric, this is the website of a CEE-OH-TOO 'scientist' are you sure
that Idso isn't using degrees when he should use radians ;-)

Seriously, you should get your data directly from NASA or UAH,
anything from a fossil fool website is suspect. Look at what Idso
does with USHCN data, he throws away three or four decades of
data, ignores important corrections, and presents it one cherry
picked site at a time.


(Eric Swanson) wrote in message ...
I just noticed an error in the Idsos' co2science web site .

Their presentation of the data from Spencer and Christy's MSU LT is flawed.

http://www.co2science.org/temperatures/msu.htm

The web page allows one to calculate temperature trends between different
years and also between various combinations of latitude and longitude.
They list minimum and maximum latitudes as "-90" and "90". The problem
is that the MSU LT data is only available between 82.5S and 82.5N.

Try the calculation with the latitude range of -90 and -75. Then try it
between -90 and -85.

And, yes, I'm reasonably sure that they are using the S & C product, but
version D, which looks almost identical to the current version 5.1 of the LT
The calculated global trend between 1979 and 2003 is +0.080 deg C/decade
close to that from S & C's web sit, which was +0.082 deg C/dec.

While one is at it, notice the big positive spike in 1980 for the data between
latitudes -85 and -75. That spike propagates thru the Southern Hemisphere
poleward of 45S. To see it, look at the data between -90 and -45. I suggest
that this spike causes the trend calculated for the entire SH to be smaller
than it would be if that spike were found to be an error and removed from S
& C's data set. For a part of 1980, only one MSU was in orbit, that on
NOAA 6.