View Single Post
  #3   Report Post  
Old August 13th 04, 07:21 PM posted to uk.sci.weather
Philip Eden Philip Eden is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by Weather-Banter: Jul 2003
Posts: 6,134
Default Whither television (and by extension tv forecasts)?


"Martin Rowley" wrote in
message ...
The following are extracted from an article in today's (Friday)

"Daily
Mail": ..... I thought it might strike a chord with some here -

as it
did me. The full article was written by Barry Norman, on the

modern-day
television scene. The problem is, does anyone take any notice, or

are
we all to be lumped together as 'boring old fa**s' who have seen

better
days? I hope not.

" I regard myself .... as a fairly bright bloke and when I

embarked on a
career in TV ... I decided to treat my audience as if it were as

bright

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
(see
below)

as me. It was a philosophy that seemed to work for nigh on 30

years ..."

" Increasingly, and alarmingly, television dumbs down and talks

down.
There was a time, and you don't have to be very old to remember

this,
when programmes on specialist subjects were presented by people

who knew
something about them. Now they tend to be presented by people

whose
knowledge consists of what the 18-year old researcher has told

them and
who are there simply because they bounce about, grin a lot and

look good
on TV. "

snip

Couldn't agree more. And I'm, erm, fortunate (I guess) that
I am able to say that to one or two of those TV executives
face to face. But if they don't listen to Barry Norman they
certainly won't listen to me.

I'm doubtful about the subjunctive "as if it were" in the above
sentence (he does say he's "bright" so he should expect to
have his grammar queried), and in any case, an audience can't
really be collectively bright, certainly not in a way that it could
be compared to an individual (i.e. Mr.Norman), so "as if they
were ..." would, in my opinion, be better.

Philip Eden